Attleboro House, Oak Bluffs
508-693-4346 (leave a message and they will call you back)
$105
shared bathrooms
The Farmhouse B&B, North Tisbury
www.mvfarmhouse.com
$110-$165
The Red Hat B&B, West Tisbury
www.theredhat.com
$115 with shared bath
Duck Inn, Aquinnah
www.gayheadrealty.com/DuckInnofMarthasVineyard.html
$115-$195
hot tub
Pet Friendly!
The Bayberry Inn, West Tisbury
mvbayberry.vineyard.net
shared bath $125, private bath $190
The Tivoli Inn, Oak Bluffs
www.tivoliinn.com
shared bath $125-$155, private bath $165-$235
Narragansett House, Oak Bluffs
www.narragansetthouse.com
$125-$275
The Nashua House Hotel, Oak Bluffs
www.nashuahouse.com
$119 for a single, $139-$149 for doubles, all shared baths
Menemsha Inn & Cottages, Menemsha
www.menemshainn.com
$145-$190
Clark House Inn, Vineyard Haven
www.clarkhouseinn.com
$150-$235
Arend’s Samoset-on-the-Sound, Oak Bluffs
www.samosetinn.com
$155-$195
some rooms have shared baths
Marni’s House, Vineyard Haven
www.marnishouse.com
$175-$200
one room allows pets
Admiral Benbow Inn, Oak Bluffs
www.admiral-benbow-inn.com
$185-$215
one room sleeps 4 adults
Hanover House Inn, Vineyard Haven
www.hanoverhouseinn.com
$185-$235
Dockside Inn, Oak Bluffs
www.vineyardinns.com/dockside.html
$185-$235
The Beach House on the Ocean, Oak Bluffs
www.beachhousemv.com
$190-$205
rollaway bed to accommodate 3rd person in room for $20 extra
Island Inn, Oak Bluffs
www.islandinn.com
2 adults $200-$235, 4 adults $275-$385
pool, tennis and golf
Pet Friendly!
Lambert’s Cove Inn, West Tisbury
www.lambertscoveinn.com
$220-$350
restaurant, pool, spa and tennis on site
The Inn at Blueberry Hill, Chilmark
www.blueberryinn.com
$262-$318
lap pool, spa and restaurant on site
Beach Plum Inn, Menemsha
www.beachpluminn.com/theinn.htm
$275-$400
Lots more B&Bs are listed on this page:
http://www.sunsol.com/ccvd/lodging/mthvinbb.html
Many of them close down in the winter and won’t take reservations until spring, or at least until January. It's hard to reach anyone in the off-season even to check rates (I tried), but if you leave messages, some of them will call you back. I assume their response times will improve in the spring and summer.